Canada’s
reluctance to raise interest rates much beyond those in the U.S. is an
opportunity for U.S. investors to profit by buying Canadian bonds,
according to Pacific Investment Management Co., the world’s largest
manager of bond funds.
The difference in yields between Canadian
and U.S. two-year notes widened Tuesday to the most since January 2004,
as investors increased bets that Canada’s key rate will diverge from the
U.S. rate. That may not happen if quantitative easing in the U.S. and
growing demand for commodities bolsters the Canadian dollar and damps
demand for the nation’s exports, prompting Bank of Canada Governor Mark
Carney to hold off from rate increases, said Edward Devlin, a money
manager at Pimco.
“If rates don’t change in the U.S. and Canada,
and you sold your U.S. two-year note and bought a Canadian two-year
note, you are tripling” yield, said Devlin, who heads Pimco’s Canadian
portfolio management team. “With the interest rate differential where it
is now, we think that is a relatively attractive place to invest
especially for a U.S.-based investor.”
Mr. Carney left the
benchmark target rate at 1% last month, following three consecutive
increases to gauge the global recovery and avoiding a divergence with
the Federal Reserve, which has locked its benchmark rate in a range of
zero to 0.25% since December 2008. Mr. Carney said in a Sept. 24
interview on CNBC that “there are limits to the divergence that there
can be between Canada and the United States.”
Elsewhere in credit
markets, the extra yield investors demand to hold the debt of Canada’s
corporations rather than its federal government, was unchanged yesterday
at 135 basis points, or 1.35%age points. Spreads reached 134 basis
points Nov. 16, the narrowest gap since March.
Breakeven Rates
In
provincial bond markets, relative yields were unchanged at 53 basis
points. They reached 51 basis points on Nov. 16, the tightest spreads
since April.
Canadian 10-year breakeven rates, which measure the
difference in yield between inflation-linked and cash bonds and gauges
price expectations, jumped to 2.275% Tuesday, its highest level since
May. Statistics Canada Tuesday said inflation in the country advanced at
the fastest pace in two years, accelerating to 2.4% in October after a
1.9% gain in September.
Triple the Yield
“With
a strong currency, it’s very difficult for the Bank of Canada to get
too far ahead of the” Fed, said Devlin. In addition to the extra yield
on Canadian bonds, investors have “the benefit of the dollar if you
think it’s going up.”
Canada’s currency has gained 19% against the
U.S. dollar since the start of 2009. The Canadian currency fell 0.6% to
CUS$1.0246 per U.S. dollar yesterday in Toronto from CUS$1.0187 the
prior day. One Canadian dollar buys 97.78 U.S. cents.
Devlin
declined to comment on specific Pimco trades. The fund manages over US$8
billion in assets on behalf of Canadian clients, he said. Pimco, a unit
of the Munich-based insurer Allianz SE, managed US$1.236 trillion of
assets as of September.
Canadian two-year notes were yielding
1.65% yesterday, compared with 0.445% in the U.S, widening the spread to
121 basis points, the highest since Jan. 14, 2004. The spread has
averaged 83 basis points this year. One basis point is 0.01%age point.
Canadian
10-year notes, yielding 3.09% Tuesday, are trading 33 basis points
above U.S. notes. The average spread between Canadian and U.S. 10-year
notes has been 4.8 basis points this year.
Canadian government
bonds have returned 7.3% this year, and are headed for an 8.8% annual
return, the most since 2008, when they returned 12%, Bank of America
Merrill Lynch data show. Global government bonds have returned 5.7% this
year, and U.S. Treasuries have generated an 8.6% gain.
Canadian
bonds also will benefit from the country’s relatively better fiscal
position at a time of heightened sovereign credit risk, while investors
are less concerned about inflation in Canada since the country’s central
bank refrained from printing money, Devlin said. That will sustain
demand and reduce volatility of longer-dated bonds, he said.
“People
who look to quality come to Canada because of sovereign debt issues,”
Devlin said, adding he expects real rates of return will stay relatively
low and inflation expectations will remain anchored so “the backend of
Canada’s yield curve stays relatively less volatile than the back end of
the U.S. yield curve.”
In an article published Nov. 19 on Pimco’s
website, Devlin said the Newport Beach, California-based firm is
“long-term bullish” on the Canadian dollar, though there could be
volatility because of policy-driven “distortions” coming primarily from
the U.S. and China. Devlin cited risks associated with any potential
drop in commodity prices, the effects of a higher Canadian dollar
fuelled by monetary and currency policies in China and the U.S., and
sovereign credit problems in other countries.