The
Canadian dollar may be overvalued based on various measures, but economists believe it could move higher yet.
Different models value the loonie, which has been hovering around parity
with the U.S. dollar, at different levels, but trading at more than
it's worth. Still, given a variety of factors, it's expected to stay at
lofty heights.
BMO Nesbitt Burns, for one, says its model, which factors in commodity
prices, interest rates and inflation differentials, pegs the fair value
of the currency at about 93 cents U.S., while the Organization for
Economic Co-ordination and Development puts the loonie's purchasing
power parity value at just 82 cents.
Still other models, according to economist Charles St-Arnaud of Nomura
Securities International in New York, show it overvalued by 10 per cent,
15 cent and even 30 per cent or more, though he believes it's not
"significantly" overvalued at all, based on various factors.
While valuations are all over the place, based on different models and
against various currencies, BMO expects the loonie to trade at or above
parity this year and next.
"Most models show the Canadian dollar is overvalued, but that doesn't
mean the currency can't deviate a little further from its fundamentals,"
said BMO economist Benjamin Reitzes. "The ducks are all in a row for
the loonie to fly still higher."
Here are four reasons why, according to Mr. Reitzes:
1. Exposure to commodity prices. "Rising commodity prices increase our
terms of trade, making Canadians relatively wealthier and boosting the
loonie."
2. Fiscal and financial strength. "While household balance sheets are
now a little stretched, a sound financial system makes Canada a more
attractive investment destination."
3. Interest rate spreads. "We expect the Bank of Canada to resume
tightening in May, with the policy rate rising 100 basis points to 2 per
cent by year-end. That should widen Canada-U.S. interest rate spreads
at the short end through most of 2011, which will benefit the C$."
4. Weakness of the U.S. dollar. "Fiscal and financial sector issues
plague the U.S., and solid global growth feeds risk appetites, none of
which bode well for the greenback. Its role as a reserve currency is
also being questioned."
The loonie took off at the beginning of the year, though has lately
lagged other currencies. But it would be a mistake to see that lag as
the most likely trend this year, said David Watt, senior currency
strategist at RBC Dominion Securities, citing, among other things, the
Bank of Canada.
"While the BoC remains cautious and inflation pressures in Canada are
currently benign, the BoC is going to raise rates this year," Mr. Watt
said, adding that, like Mr. Reitzes, he expects the central bank's
benchmark overnight rate to reach 2 per cent by the end of the year,
beginning with increases in the second quarter.
"The retreat in BoC rate expectatations is inappropriate," he said. "As
they are reversed, [the Canadian dolar] will regain traction."